Member Blogs: Tuckota Kirklan Fadgmo

Got something to say to Fish & Game Commissioners

Upland Idaho's Wingshooters Glossary

All original pictures and video posted to UplandIdaho.com are copyright of Upland Idaho LLC or the individual posting

Our home page
Hunting stories, maps, pictures, and more
Our Biology and Conservation Information
Hunting and Fishing trips and tips
Links to our affliates and friends
Shop for unique outdoor items
Become a member, sign-up, read our posts
Pages submitted by our Members

Upland Idaho Forum - Where have all the Chukars gone?
Upland Idaho Forum
Upland Idaho Forum
Home | My Files | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Hunting
 Upland Bird Hunting
 Where have all the Chukars gone?
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

TEvans
Quail>10 posts

USA
13 Posts

Posted - 04/09/2010 :  17:50:20  Show Profile
I have hunted chukars for 37 years in Oregon. During my first 15 years, daily limits were common. Over the past 20 years, I seldom limit out. Many have said the decrease in chukar numbers is due to weather, but I just do not buy that we have had 20 years of bad weather. The decline is surely not due to hunting pressure. Are we killing our chukars with changes in farming practices with the use of fertilizers and pestisides? Have the chukars populations in Idaho decreased over the past 20 years? Is there anything we can do to improve future chukars populations?

Kirklan
Chukar>500 Posts

USA
756 Posts

Posted - 04/09/2010 :  19:18:26  Show Profile
quote:
Originally posted by TEvans

Are we killing our chukars with changes in farming practices with the use of fertilizers and pestisides? Have the chukars populations in Idaho decreased over the past 20 years? Is there anything we can do to improve future chukars populations?



I don't think pesticides or farming practices are to blame. I would venture to say that 99% of chukars do not even live close to agriculture areas. I certainly have never hunted chukar anywhere near a farm. Pesticides used today are a lot less invasive and have a much shorter "life" than pesticides from the 60's and 70's. If pesticides were to blame, then populations should have been decimated by the late 70's. Huns and pheasants seem to be doing very well on our farm and huns in particular have increased significantly in the last 10-15 years.

Just 4 seasons ago in 2005, ID had a record year for chukar. It was the second highest year on record and the highest since the late 60's. If I recall correctly we had a mild winter, excellent rains right through spring and then great weather for the chukar hatch resulting in great recruitment.

Habitat is the largest contributing factor in any wild game bird population. If the habitat hasn't changed appreciably in the time frame you suggested then maybe disease or West Nile virus is affecting the birds.



Edited by - Kirklan on 04/09/2010 19:20:37
Go to Top of Page

Anthony
Sage-grouse>150 posts

USA
245 Posts

Posted - 04/09/2010 :  20:54:04  Show Profile
Actually where Tevans is referring to is along the lower Deschutes & John Day Rivers (I assume). These areas are practically all agricultural areas where they dry farm wheat and barley up on top. I shot many chukars with a gullet full of wheat. Some of the best places to find chukars was right where the canyon starts and the wheat field ends. I doubt it has anything to do with pesticides, but I don’t know. I know the Oregon Fish and Wildlife used to take samples from the geese taken in the wheat fields to check the effects of pesticides.

I think the fact that they can dry farm in this region is more indicative why numbers are lower. The Deschutes River is perfect chukar habitat except that is too close to the Pacific and many Springs it get way to much rain. Also, fires are a lot more common nowadays with the increase of people visiting these areas. I too remember when I first started hunting chukars on the Deschutes River there seemed to be a lot of birds and shortly after there numbers dropped for many years, but I think it was mostly weather related.
Go to Top of Page

grousehunter 61
Sage-grouse>150 posts

USA
240 Posts

Posted - 04/10/2010 :  07:12:49  Show Profile
I live here on the Salmon River, our bird population is almost non-existent. In years past we had birds all over the place, it was nothing to see a hen with chicks on the road, now nothing. We do not have any agriculture here in the canyon, so its not pesticides. We haven't had any new building, no room, but we have had late cold, spring rains that have washed out a lot of nests and insect life. I think the key to it all is the insects are not out due to the cold weather so late into the year and the young birds have nothing to eat and are starving to death.
Go to Top of Page

n/a
deleted

43 Posts

Posted - 04/11/2010 :  14:35:49  Show Profile
I feel the pain!! The Jarbidge and the Bruneau are both hurting bad. I found a few birds,and I even saw a lot in one place. But that was in the area of the old fire. The area was grazed off and the birds flushed WAY out in front. The most birds I saw in one day was probably 40 total. Five or six years ago I would see between 200 and 500 per day. To go from 20 + coveys a day to one, or maybe two stinks. It does sound like the Brownlee area hunters have good numbers so I have been telling all the hunters I know that we should all go over there. Ron
Go to Top of Page

gwebb86
Sage-grouse>150 posts

USA
263 Posts

Posted - 04/11/2010 :  18:12:49  Show Profile
as for hunting on the john day and Deschutes I would say last year was the worst and the year before wasnt great either. The 2007 through 05 was great. I think the low numbers recently are due to the fires. My brother worked many of those fires on the deschutes and he wold say he saw hundreds of chukar so for them to die off that quick I would say they just were not getting the food they needed. I also so while hunting the john day that the birds would comtinue to stay in there normal spots but would see you coming and flush way out on you. The year before we got 30 in a day with 4 of us. I dont know if farming would have much to do with it but I believe chukar bounce back and forth really quick.
Go to Top of Page

Tuckota
Supporting Member - The Legend!

1425 Posts

Posted - 04/12/2010 :  06:19:50  Show Profile  Visit Tuckota's Homepage
As gwebb86 mentioned, chukar numbers bounce back and fourth quite regularly. Add that to more chukar hunters due to the lack of pheasants and places to hunt pheasants and there will be times you might not see as many birds. I'm not saying that any of you don't hunt hard, but with the changes over time you have to work a little harder to find them. Statistics show that the birds are still there. I don't know why other areas wouldn't be the same, but the Brownlee and Lucky Peak bird counts show this. TEvans mentioned twenty years. The Brownlee count in 1989 was 54.1 birds per square mile. Twenty years later 73.7 birds per square mile. In 1993 the birds hit a low of 17.6 birds per square mile to rebound to 88.0 birds the following year. That number stayed about there for four years and than continued to rise through 2005 when we had 173.8 birds per square miles. Guess what, it was not uncommon to see many chukars within 2 to 3 hundred yards of the road. The numbers declined each year from that to 71.5 to 42.2 to 37.8 in 2008. 2009 the bird count doubled to 73.7. Hopefully 2010 will be over 100 birds. Although lucky peak counts show lower number of birds per square mile the data proves about the same. The birds are still out there, it's what we do to find them that's making the difference. If it's any consolation, I've been walking and training the dogs in areas from Brownlee to Mountain Home and have seen more pairs of chukar and huns than I can recall in many years. So, if spring conditions are favorable it looks to be a great year.
Tuckota

http://tuckerschukars.blogspot.com
Go to Top of Page

n/a
deleted

43 Posts

Posted - 04/12/2010 :  19:06:30  Show Profile
Tuckota, You said

“Statistics show that the birds are still there. I don't know why other areas wouldn't be the same, but the Brownlee and Lucky Peak bird counts show this.”

You got to be kidding right? Show me one Statistic for the Bruneau canyon, Jarbidge Canyon, The Bennet hills, or the South hills below Twin Falls that back up your thinking.
Do you really think all areas of the state from the Nevada line to Salmon and from Oregon to Burley all have the same habitat, Weather, and nesting conditions? Why don't they fly the canyon lands for Chukar counts?
Here are the facts. Hunters around the state are seeing drastically lower numbers of chukars and some are on here telling you this yet you still don't believe anything anyone says. Why are you not wanting to realize that the numbers are off in other areas? Are you that afraid that limits will be cut? You kind of sound like a cheerleader for a loosing team. You can say chukar hunting is fantastic all you want. We know what we know, and what we see is not through rose colored glasses.
I know you don't believe a word I say but the canyon lands chukar populations are hurting. Even with an amazing nesting season we will NOT see record numbers of birds. Not in one year.
As a side note my Sage grouse Lek counts are down about 50% from last year. I contacted the Biologist that is flying my area and all of the Diamond A. He told me that that is about what he is seeing. 50% decrease in Sage Grouse. Ron
Go to Top of Page

Tuckota
Supporting Member - The Legend!

1425 Posts

Posted - 04/12/2010 :  20:07:35  Show Profile  Visit Tuckota's Homepage
Ron. No, I'm not kidding. Taka a look at the F&G bird counts. I'm well aware that your area might have different habitat and weather. Just like other states may have. But the chukar populations fluctuate everywhere else. Evidently your area defies logic. I'm sorry but I've seen more people commenting on the positive bird count this year than the negative as you say. I do believe what you and others say. I just wonder about the effort you have put in. I am a cheerleader for the birds and my glasses aren't tinted. No you won't have a record season in one year but you might have some great improvement. I never once mentioned sage grouse. I don't know the future of them because I spend my time finding chukar.
Tuckota

http://tuckerschukars.blogspot.com
Go to Top of Page

Patrick
Supporting Member

USA
129 Posts

Posted - 04/12/2010 :  20:41:11  Show Profile
Gents, remember civility in discourse. From what I read of your accounts, Ron, you have many valid points backed up by personal observation within your stated areas. But I think sharing viewpoints should be just that; sharing differing points of view while respecting each others' opinions.

I will probably weigh in with Tukota on my expectations of a good year, and as a math teacher, the historical data of increase in bird counts from 93 to 94 on one particular area went up fourfold plus! That statistic alone does shed light on the variability and potential increase in populations that may occur in a particular area.

In my chukar hunting grounds, where I spend the majority of my time, I have seen the fluctuations in bird numbers, but I have always run into enough birds to have action. I hope for the best this year with a decent spring and high insect populations coupled with the rain being gentle during brood hatches. Let's hope for the best populations in all areas for all of us chasing the chucks.

Patrick Lynch

Life begins at the end of your comfort zone.
Go to Top of Page

IdahoNavy
Supporting Member

332 Posts

Posted - 04/12/2010 :  22:36:29  Show Profile  Visit IdahoNavy's Homepage
Awe heck!
Here's a story about Tuckota. A friend was at a check station near Twin. Tuckota, always proud of his Chukar limit, pulls up and says he'd been Chukar huntin in the South Hills and did they want to see his license, Chukars and his dawgs. The F&G augmentee says "yes sir" to all except the dawgs. So Tuckota shows his license and then reaches into his game vest and pulls out 8 beautiful black and white birds. The F&G augmentee tells Tuck that these are Magpies and Tuck yells, "What the hell is a Magpie!" "Hell! you mean all these years I'd thought I'd been killin Chukars, but instead I'd been killin 8 birds that ain't even a gamebird. So now I can see why Tuck thinks Idaho is full of Chukars even when there ain't any.

Moral of the story: Tuck you ain't gotta climb 4K ft to get a Magpie.
Go to Top of Page

n/a
deleted

43 Posts

Posted - 04/13/2010 :  03:47:31  Show Profile
Oh so I don't know how to hunt chukar and I am too lazy to get out and do it?
That is why no one in the Bruneau river, Jarbidge river, Salmon river and many other area are not seeing birds. I dare you to hunt there. You have your self an area with some birds enjoy it. The rest of us I guess are just lazy no good do nothing wannabe chukar hunters.
I am not able to stay on this site with this kind of a guy any longer. You go out and kill between 500 and 800 birds a year.
When I tell guys around here you do that they think you are a game hog. So here is the deal. I am gone,finished with this site, and this is my last post. You can only insult me and the rest of the chukar hunters so far. You think you are some kind of special chukar hunting god. Good luck shooting 1000 birds this year. I won't be here to read about it. Ron
Go to Top of Page

Tuckota
Supporting Member - The Legend!

1425 Posts

Posted - 04/13/2010 :  06:33:12  Show Profile  Visit Tuckota's Homepage
Patrick you are right. I apologize for getting to the point that makes it not fun to read posts. This is a fun site with lots of good, fun people on it. It should stay fun and informative.
IdahNavy. Now I know why the birds were so tough to eat.
Tuckota

http://tuckerschukars.blogspot.com
Go to Top of Page

Shrthrcrzy
Supporting Member

USA
662 Posts

Posted - 04/13/2010 :  07:16:03  Show Profile  Visit Shrthrcrzy's Homepage
Wow..this is starting to look like most of the shooting sportsman threads.

" Never kick a fresh Turd on a hot day"
-Harry Truman
Go to Top of Page

swingandamiss
Quail>10 posts

21 Posts

Posted - 04/13/2010 :  09:58:07  Show Profile
Idaho Ron you have got to be kidding me, have another beer.
Go to Top of Page

situk
Supporting Member

USA
564 Posts

Posted - 04/13/2010 :  10:31:15  Show Profile
Tucker and all,
Thanks for keeping things positive, I enjoy all of your threads and pictures. I know you guys had a banner year, and I’m glad. I had a banner year last year when you were all suffering. And now, I have to drive up to your neck of the words to find birds. Keep the good news coming.
Todd

Todd Petersen
Supporting Member

Edited by - situk on 04/13/2010 10:32:19
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 2 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic  Topic Locked
 Printer Friendly
Jump To:
Upland Idaho Forum © 2010 Upland Idaho LLC Go To Top Of Page
Powered By: Snitz Forums 2000